Sometimes Thank yous are needed
Jun. 15th, 2010 04:06 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
pinksoniaDoes anyone else use Goodreads? I like it as a way to keep track of the books I read each year -- much better than my old word document method. Anyway, I've been a member of the Adults reading Young Adult Fiction group (called Wildthings) for about a year now. I think I'm in the minority in that group due to the fact that I am neither a teacher nor a mother, but reading through the messages has prompted me to thank my mother numerous times over the last year for the way she raised me.
Many of the people (mostly women) who post in the group do so because they read every book their child reads in order to make sure the themes are appropriate. Now, I'm not a mother, so I can only come at this situation from the view point of the child, but I would have stopped reading or I would have become the biggest sneak imaginable -- hiding every book I found regardless of how "appropriate" it might have been. Then again, I am and have always been a very private person.
I come from a huge family of readers. We trade books all the time. No family get together is complete without an exchange of books accompanied by an "I think you'll like this," if fact every time I visit my parents I am greeted by a new stack of books in my childhood room, things my parents have read since the last time I was home and think I might like. My grandmother does the same thing but with articles which can be sent through the mail. Still, all through my childhood I can only remember reading two things around the same time as my mother: Christy when the television series came out and Anne of Green Gables and its sequels right before we went to Prince Edward Island on vacation. The first book even involves an instance of Statutory rape, but there was never a sense that I couldn't read it or that we needed to have a "very special" discussion about it. I was allowed to read whatever I wanted, whenever I wanted, and trusted to get things or not get them.
So, once again -- thank you Mom (and Dad) for your hands off approach to my reading material growing up. Thank you for taking me to the library often, and for letting me check out anything that looked interesting.
Many of the people (mostly women) who post in the group do so because they read every book their child reads in order to make sure the themes are appropriate. Now, I'm not a mother, so I can only come at this situation from the view point of the child, but I would have stopped reading or I would have become the biggest sneak imaginable -- hiding every book I found regardless of how "appropriate" it might have been. Then again, I am and have always been a very private person.
I come from a huge family of readers. We trade books all the time. No family get together is complete without an exchange of books accompanied by an "I think you'll like this," if fact every time I visit my parents I am greeted by a new stack of books in my childhood room, things my parents have read since the last time I was home and think I might like. My grandmother does the same thing but with articles which can be sent through the mail. Still, all through my childhood I can only remember reading two things around the same time as my mother: Christy when the television series came out and Anne of Green Gables and its sequels right before we went to Prince Edward Island on vacation. The first book even involves an instance of Statutory rape, but there was never a sense that I couldn't read it or that we needed to have a "very special" discussion about it. I was allowed to read whatever I wanted, whenever I wanted, and trusted to get things or not get them.
So, once again -- thank you Mom (and Dad) for your hands off approach to my reading material growing up. Thank you for taking me to the library often, and for letting me check out anything that looked interesting.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2010-06-16 03:34 pm (UTC)My mom monitored my reading for the first ten years of my life, which I am actually grateful for. She learned from my sister that trusting the school system to pick "appropriate" books was out of the question after my sister read a book about abuse at age eight and was terribly freaked out. :( After my first ten years, I really was able to read whatever I wanted, but my taste has always leaned towards classic literature. I read Pride and Prejudice at age eleven, and Jane Austen's other books subsequently followed. Charlotte Bronte followed at age twelve. Louisa May Alcott at thirteen, etc., all the way up to my recent fascination with Russian literature. :)
BTW, I've read all of LMM's books, but I don't remember the incident of statutory rape which you reference in Anne of Green Gables. I keep meaning to reread certain books, but there's always so many other books that I haven't read yet that distract me.
no subject
Date: 2010-06-17 01:42 am (UTC)I think my use of the word first was confusing. I meant there was statutory rape in Christy not in Anne of Green Gables. I re-read Green Gables through House of Dreams last year and have been meaning to do the rest for a while.